Talk:The Problem by Mr. Conway/@comment-172.56.42.200-20160210180451

I feel like you are looking at this from a very set point of veiw. There are direct reasons as to why rebellions broke out and people left. It is not a problem with the system, but a negligence from leaders to their men. Players have no obligation to stay once their leader deserts them, as we see on countless times with Auel. This then sets a terrible  precedent for the militaries that come later down the road.

It is the lack of sense of loyalty and honor in serving that kills militaries.

I choose to follow a leader til the bitter end of the guild, hoping for it to slowly grow back.

New militarists seem to believe that once there is a slight setback, then the military is dead.

The glimmering peice of hope I have seen in this area is Gilnean, no matter how cancerous their system may be. They have been together for about 2 months now, have a steady flow of members, and do not have rebellions happening every 24 hours. As well, with the set backs they have faced such as their leader being banned on multiple occasions, they have responded wonderfully. Tactifully shifting their central command.

This is the true problem,

This is what we need to solve.

Macbeth